Tasks vs credits, a linear editor vs a visual canvas, and who should pick which
Zapier bills per successful action and keeps the editor simple, while Make bills per module run on a visual canvas. Here is how the two differ in practice, and how to choose.
Both tools do the same basic thing. Something happens in one app (a form is submitted, a row is added), and the tool pushes the data into another app (a CRM, Slack, a spreadsheet). The differences show up in how you build the workflow, how you are billed for it, and what happens when a run goes wrong.
Zapier calls a workflow a Zap. You build it top to bottom: one trigger, then one or more action steps. Zapier states that it connects more than 10,000 apps, the largest catalog of the three tools the automation course covers. The editor is linear, which makes a first two-step Zap quick to build.
Make calls a workflow a scenario and draws it as a canvas of connected modules. Branches, routers and loops are visible as shapes, so you can see where a lead went and why. Make lists a library of 3,500+ applications. The canvas is more work to learn and more honest about what a workflow really does.
Billing is where the two differ most.
Zapier bills in tasks. Its help center defines a task as "any successful action that runs in Zapier." Triggers, filters, paths and Formatter steps do not count. A Zap with two action steps that runs once uses two tasks. The Free plan includes 100 tasks a month, two-step Zaps and 15-minute polling (checked November 2026).
Make bills in credits. Its pricing page says that "as of August 27, credits are the billing unit in Make," and that most module actions cost one credit each. The catch is bundles: a trigger that returns ten rows makes every later module run ten times. Make's own example shows one run costing 31 operations. The Free plan includes 1,000 credits a month (checked November 2026).
So a simple lead intake that fires once per form submission uses a handful of tasks or credits per lead on either tool. A scenario that polls a sheet and processes many rows per run gets expensive on Make faster than you would guess, while a Zap with five action steps burns five tasks per lead on Zapier.
Zapier has Copilot, which drafts Zaps from a plain-English description (daily message limit on Free, unlimited on paid plans), AI by Zapier steps on paid plans billed in tasks, and Zapier Agents as a separate add-on with its own activity quota. Make offers Make AI Agents, which it says are "available on all plans," plus an assistant named Maia. Both let you put a model step inside a workflow. Neither checks the model's answer for you.
Both are cloud only. You cannot self-host either one. Zapier is quicker to start. Make rewards a second week of effort with a clearer picture of branching logic, and its visual bubbles show how many bundles passed through each module, which is useful when you are hunting a lead that went missing.
A 5-person ops team with one or two intake forms and no appetite for debugging should start on Zapier. The cost is predictable and the editor is hard to break.
A marketer who runs a CRM and wants leads scored, split by region and tagged in several systems will hit Zapier's linear editor fast. Make's routers and visible branches fit that work, as long as the marketer watches the bundle count.
A team that already pays for Zapier and has 20 Zaps should not migrate for the sake of it. Pricing differences matter less than the hours spent rebuilding.
The AI Automation with Zapier, Make and n8n course has you build the same Tally-to-HubSpot lead intake on Zapier, Make and n8n, so you feel the differences instead of reading about them. Free plans on Zapier and Make are enough for the build. Chapter 3 opens the HubSpot contact your run created and checks the fields, because a green run is not the same as a correct record. Chapter 4 routes each lead to one owner with a fallback, and chapter 5 adds one fenced AI step with a daily spending cap. By the end you have costed the manual task, built it three ways and picked the tool for your own team on evidence.